|
Reviews
From Booklist , February 15, 1994.:
Ages 5-8. The first sentence of this story ("A long, long time ago, and far away, there lived a King") is fairy-tale boilerplate. The second ("This King was very poor, and he was not very clever") is not. The king makes marriages for his three beautiful daughters with the Sun, the Moon, and the Raven.
When he goes to visit his children, he finds that all of them are living better than he is. From each son-in-law, the king learns a marvelous trick, but when he tries to practice the tricks for his wife, they don't work. The Sun can fry an egg on his head, but the king can't.
The engaging simpleton of a monarch is more closely related to James Marshall's Stupids than to Prince Charming, and Hillenbrand's oil and oil pastel paintings, strong on golden reds, oranges, and golds, emphasize the gap. The king has patches on his sleeves, holes in his stockings, and the countenance of a cherubic Humpty-Dumpty Lenin.
The humor is not directed at the king in a mean-spirited way. The monarch learns his limitations in the end, and readers--like the queen--will be happy. Mary Harris Veeder Copyright© 1994, American Library Association. All rights reserved
From Horn Book:
A poor and foolish king offers to give his three daughters in marriage to the sun, the moon, and the raven, respectively, if they will keep him warm, give him light, and help him pick up the grain he had dropped out of a mouse-eaten sack.
Ginsburg is at the top of her form in this retelling of an old Russian tale, illustrated with Hillenbrand's chunky caricatures, which are sure to evoke chuckles. -- Copyright © 1994 The Horn Book, Inc. All rights reserved.
More of Will's Books
|