|
Reviews
From Booklist , October 1, 1996
Gr. 3--5, younger for reading aloud. Who doesn't have a favorite, thoroughly ugly picture-book villain? Move side, Shrek [Shrek! by William Steig (1990)] and Loathly Lady [Sir Gawain and the Loathly Lady by Selina Hastings (1985)], make room for Hillenbrand's trio of ugly-to-the-bone antagonists.
In this pourquoi tale, set in a time before humans had fire, coyote allows himself to be flattered into stealing fire from its guardians, three gnarled, gruesome, ghastly evil spirits. Along the way, coyote receives help from squirrel and frog, who are forever changed by the experience.
The animals win, and coyote shows people how to make fire by rubbing sticks together. A strong read-aloud choice for younger children; older elementary-school students may want to compare this with other recent coyote or trickster tales. The author's note provides sources and additional information on coyote tales.
The illustrator's note touches on his research regarding the Pacific Northwest Indians, who originally told this tale. There is a sense of respect toward readers, the story, and traditional telling here. Karen Morgan Copyright© 1996, American Library Association. All rights reserved
From Horn Book
Illustrated by Will Hillenbrand. Coyote is not immune to admiration. When his People ask him in flattering terms to get Fire for them, his chest puffs out and he promises to think of a plan. In fact, he steals a plan from his two shape-changing sisters that requires a relay race of cooperative animals, notably Squirrel, whose tail is permanently curled by the heat of the Fire Stick, and Frog, whose tail is forevermore removed by the pursuing evil spirits.
The plan works perfectly, except that Fire is swallowed by a tree at the end of the long chase. But crafty Coyote is equal to this challenge; he teaches his People to rub wood together to make sparks to start a fire. A well-told story with inventive oil and oil pastel illustrations of the sturdy People, the helpful animals, and the serio-comic evil spirits, green and bulbous.
Accenting all are the sharp portraits of the scrawny yet supple trickster hero, prancing with admiration for himself. Good notes by reteller and illustrator are appended.
More of Will's Books
|