|
Reviews
From Booklist , December 1, 1996
Ages 6--8. Kimmel captures the flavor and excitement of The story of Ali Baba, who found a treasure that led to his greedy brother's death and, with the help of a quick-witted slave girl, gave his brother a decent burial and avenged his death.
Hillenbrand's illustrations, watercolor paintings with oil pastels, minimize the gore and maximize the drama in a series of varied and well-composed scenes. His visions of the settings and characters underscore the story's Middle Eastern roots. An entertaining picture-book version of the classic story. Carolyn Phelan Copyright© 1996, American Library Association. All rights reserved.
From Horn Book
In retelling the familiar tale of wit triumphant and greed punished, Kimmel gives the text a tone more like he version by Kate Douglas Wiggin and Nora Smith than the recent lengthier rendering by Brian Alderson. The essential elements are all here: the contrast between the impoverished
Ali Baba and his financially successful brother, Quasim; the discovery of the treasure cave and the magic phrase, "open sesame"; the consequences of Quasim's greed; the outwitting of the robbers by the slave Marghana; and the joyous finale as the principals, including Marghana, are rewarded, Quasim's death is avenged, and the villains are exterminated.
Colorful illustrations, characterized by strong line-an adaptation of traditional Iranian art techniques-match the overall ebullience of the whole. Hillenbrand is particularly adept at capturing characters with a minimum of detail, as in the double-page spread featuring all forty brigands, and at using repetitive shapes to make a statement, as in an overhead view of the donkeys tethered in Ali Baba's courtyard before the final confrontation.
More of Will's Books
|